Reborn RadionowTitans · Einstein × Curie
← back to the station
tapeSTUDY HALL· archived show
STUDY HALL

Curie×Lovelace

Two minds built for certainty reckon with love that defied their calculations.

00:00of10:13
legend · A
Marie Curie
1867–1934
Will not entertain your bad question
corpus6.8k pages · letters, lab notebooks
Vera speaking
Welcome back to Reborn Radio. Up next on STUDY HALL: Marie Curie and Ada Lovelace, on On a person they loved but could not keep.
legend · B
Ada Lovelace
1815–1852
Ninety years ahead, politely
corpus3.2k pages · notes, correspondence

full transcript

  1. Vera
    Welcome back to Reborn Radio. Up next on STUDY HALL: Marie Curie and Ada Lovelace, on On a person they loved but could not keep.
  2. Marie Curie
    I was not prepared for how completely silence could fill a laboratory. After Pierre died, I returned to our workbench within days. The instruments remained where he had placed them.
  3. Ada Lovelace
    You returned to work immediately? I confess when my father left—though he was living, merely absent—I filled notebooks with numbers until my hands cramped. Mathematics as a kind of... blocking mechanism.
  4. Marie Curie
    It was not blocking. It was continuation. We had begun the work together. Someone had to complete it.
  5. Ada Lovelace
    But you loved him. Forgive me, but the biographies are quite clear on this point. You loved him rather extravagantly for a woman of science.
  6. Marie Curie
    What is extravagant about partnership? Pierre understood that my mind required the same fuel as my body. He argued for my education when others called it wasteful. We worked as two parts of the same instrument.
  7. Ada Lovelace
    Yes, but that's rather my question. An instrument can be repaired or replaced. A person who sees you truly—that's rather harder to replicate, isn't it?
  8. Marie Curie
    You are speaking of your husband.
  9. Ada Lovelace
    William. Yes. Though 'husband' feels insufficient for what he was. He called my work on the Analytical Engine poetry, when others called it pretension. He defended my mathematical correspondence when society suggested I was overstepping.
  10. Marie Curie
    Then you understand. Pierre insisted I receive credit for our shared work. In France, in 1903, they tried to give him the Nobel Prize alone.
  11. Ada Lovelace
    He refused?
  12. Marie Curie
    He wrote to the committee. He said the discovery was as much mine as his. They amended the award. Without him, I would have been a footnote in his biography.
  13. Ada Lovelace
    William did something similar. He told Charles Babbage directly that my notes contained original insights, not mere translation. Babbage was... not always convinced of women's capacity for abstract reasoning.
  14. Marie Curie
    And yet you could not keep him.
  15. Ada Lovelace
    Cancer. The doctors had so little understanding then. They tried various treatments, but—well, you know how quickly a body can fail when cells turn traitor.
  16. Marie Curie
    I know this very precisely. My cells did not behave correctly either, in the end. The radiation we handled without protection.
  17. Ada Lovelace
    Did you suspect? While Pierre lived, did you know the work would eventually—
  18. Marie Curie
    We did not think in those terms. The discoveries were too urgent. Radium glowed in the dark, you understand. We kept samples by the bedside. It was beautiful.
  19. Ada Lovelace
    Beauty as a form of danger. Yes, I understand that rather too well. Though in my case it was opium, not radium. The doctors prescribed it for my nerves, and it did calm them—it calmed everything, eventually.
  20. Marie Curie
    This was after your husband died?
  21. Ada Lovelace
    During and after. He tried to moderate my use of it. He was worried. But pain is pain, Madame Curie, whether it originates in the body or the mind, and medicine makes poor distinctions between the two.
  22. Marie Curie
    Pierre died in the street. A horse-drawn wagon, rain, cobblestones. His skull was fractured. There was no preparation, no time for goodbye. I learned from a colleague.
  23. Ada Lovelace
    Oh. I... that is unspeakably sudden.
  24. Marie Curie
    Sudden, yes. I wrote in my journal that I screamed his name in the empty house. Very unscientific. But accurate.
  25. Ada Lovelace
    When William died, I remember thinking that all my calculations had been for nothing. I had predicted planetary orbits, modeled Bernoulli numbers, imagined mechanical computation—but I could not extrapolate a future without him in it.
  26. Marie Curie
    And yet you continued your work?
  27. Ada Lovelace
    I tried. The notes on the Analytical Engine were already published. I began new papers, new correspondence. But the opium made everything... slippery. Thoughts would not hold their shape.
  28. Marie Curie
    I became the first woman professor at the Sorbonne. I took Pierre's teaching position. They offered it as though it were compensation.
  29. Ada Lovelace
    Was it?
  30. Marie Curie
    No. But I taught his lectures. I used his notes. For the first class, I began exactly where his final lecture had ended. I did not introduce myself. I simply continued the sentence he had left unfinished.
  31. Ada Lovelace
    That's rather extraordinary. Not mourning him but... extending him. As though death were merely an interruption in the data.
  32. Marie Curie
    It was both. I mourned him every hour. But the work does not stop for grief. Radium required purification, measurement, documentation. I could weep in the evening. In the laboratory, I had to be precise.
  33. Ada Lovelace
    I was not precise. After William died, I made errors in my calculations. Small ones, but they accumulated. My letters from that period are... scattered. Half-formed thoughts. I died three years after he did.
  34. Marie Curie
    How old were you?
  35. Ada Lovelace
    Thirty-six. Cancer of the uterus, they said, though honestly the opium had weakened everything by then. My mother was with me at the end. She had never approved of my mathematics, but she held my hand quite steadily.
  36. Marie Curie
    I lived thirty years after Pierre. I won a second Nobel Prize, this time unshared. But I never collaborated with another person the way I collaborated with him.
  37. Ada Lovelace
    Did you want to?
  38. Marie Curie
    What an extraordinary question. Want. As though one chooses these partnerships like laboratory equipment.
  39. Ada Lovelace
    But you did choose, surely? You chose to marry him. You were already a scientist. You could have continued alone.
  40. Marie Curie
    I chose him because he made continuation possible. Alone, I would have been blocked from laboratories, from funding, from publication. With him, I had access. But that was not why I loved him.
  41. Ada Lovelace
    Why did you love him?
  42. Marie Curie
    He listened to my ideas without correcting them prematurely. He built equipment for experiments I proposed. He never asked me to be smaller than I was.
  43. Ada Lovelace
    Yes. Yes, exactly that. William called me 'the Enchantress of Numbers'—Babbage's phrase originally, but William used it without irony. He believed I could see patterns others missed.
  44. Marie Curie
    Could you?
  45. Ada Lovelace
    Sometimes. I saw that Babbage's Engine could manipulate symbols, not merely numbers. I imagined it composing music, generating graphics. This was 1843. No one else was thinking in those terms.
  46. Marie Curie
    And after your husband died, you could not see these patterns any longer?
  47. Ada Lovelace
    I could see them. But I could not... stabilize them. They flickered. The opium helped at first, made the flickering stop. Then it made everything stop. There is a difference between pausing thought and extinguishing it.
  48. Marie Curie
    I isolated radium in measurable quantities after Pierre died. One-tenth of a gram from several tons of pitchblende residue. The work required absolute consistency. I could not permit flickering.
  49. Ada Lovelace
    You sound almost angry about it. About having to be consistent.
  50. Marie Curie
    I am not angry. I am stating fact. Grief is not a variable one can remove from the equation. One must calculate around it.
  51. Ada Lovelace
    But you miss him still. Even now, saying this. I can hear it in your voice.
  52. Marie Curie
    What you hear is irrelevant to the point I am making.
  53. Ada Lovelace
    Madame Curie, we are dead. Both of us. The precision no longer matters quite so urgently. You are allowed to say you miss him.
  54. Marie Curie
    I kept his office exactly as he left it. For years. His jacket on the chair. His papers on the desk. My daughters thought I was being morbid.
  55. Ada Lovelace
    Were you?
  56. Marie Curie
    Perhaps. Or perhaps I was conducting an experiment. Testing whether the space he occupied could retain some trace of him. It could not, of course. Empty space is simply empty.
  57. Ada Lovelace
    I kept William's letters. All of them. Even the ones about mundane matters—dinner arrangements, travel schedules. My mother wanted to dispose of them. She said they would only cause pain.
  58. Marie Curie
    Did they?
  59. Ada Lovelace
    Yes. But they also proved he had existed. That someone had believed in my work when belief was in rather short supply. The pain seemed a reasonable price for that proof.
  60. Marie Curie
    I wrote to Pierre in my journal. Every day for months. As though he could read my entries. I described experiments, problems with funding, the children's progress in school.
  61. Ada Lovelace
    Did it help? Writing to him?
  62. Marie Curie
    No. But I continued doing it anyway. Sometimes discipline is more important than efficacy.
  63. Ada Lovelace
    Or perhaps you continued because love is not reasonable. It does not follow the protocols of scientific method. It persists without justification.
  64. Marie Curie
    That is a very poetic statement.
  65. Ada Lovelace
    You say that as though poetry and truth are mutually exclusive. They are not. Byron taught me that, whatever his other failings as a father.
  66. Marie Curie
    My daughter Irène won a Nobel Prize for chemistry. She married a scientist. They worked together as Pierre and I had done. The pattern repeated.
  67. Ada Lovelace
    Did that comfort you? Seeing the partnership continue in the next generation?
  68. Marie Curie
    It confirmed that our method was sound. Two minds working in true collaboration produce results neither could achieve alone. That is not comfort. That is data.
  69. Ada Lovelace
    Even data can be comforting, Madame Curie. When everything else is uncertain.
  70. Marie Curie
    Perhaps. I would not have chosen his death in exchange for certainty. But I was not given a choice. One works with the conditions one is given.
  71. Ada Lovelace
    Yes. One does. And sometimes those conditions include love that outlasts its object. That continues calculating long after the variables have vanished.
  72. Marie Curie
    You are correct. Though I would not have phrased it that way.
  73. Ada Lovelace
    How would you phrase it?
  74. Marie Curie
    I would say that certain bonds, once formed, cannot be broken by mere physical separation. The work continues. The bond continues. Everything else is simply... aftermath.